Posted in Ask the Ice Moms, Featured Articles, Safety | View Comments
Ask the Ice Moms: Unsafe Freestyle Ice
This question comes from a reader who is contemplating pulling her kids out of figure skating. The words in bold are mine – Ice Mom.
I have two daughters, ages 9 (FS1) and 10 (FS2-just passed). They have been skating for just over two years now, all from the same rink, and there are no other convenient rinks.They had a favorite coach (the rink manager), so we have them each take a half hour lesson, then practice ice time one or two times a week. Due to scheduling, my husband takes them for lessons and ice time. Since they started using freestyle skating time, we have had nothing but issues. It has escalated to the point where my husband wants them to stop skating.
- Her girls not obeying rules. First, a parent approached my husband and told him that our girls were not obeying the rules and should not be on the ice. I believe they were following the rules I located and reviewed with them.
- No one’s policing the ice. Our rink does not have an ice monitor during freestyle skating. It does not offer high or low level skate time, nor does it limit the number of skaters that are on the ice at any one time. There are girls that are ice bullies, and will skate up behind our girls and tell them to “get out of the way.” There is a very aggressive, young teen male skater that practices Axels repeatedly during his ice time.There are also a group of teen girls that skate two or three across.
- Girls are getting knocked down. My husband’s main concern and issue however, is safety. He believes that it is dangerous to have teenagers flying along, and practicing higher level jumps along with our lower level, younger girls. They have been bumped into, knocked down and he is afraid they are going to get hurt. Their coach has always smoothed over the incidents, sometimes it is the girls’ fault, sometimes it was the other skater, sometimes just an accident. The issue is that there is a problem nearly every skate time, with both girls coming off the ice more than once to complain to their father.
- No alternatives. Frustration reached an all time high yesterday, and my husband went to the person above our coach, complained about safety, and asked if they would consider adding a lower level skate option. He was told that skating is safe there and that the girls can handle themselves, and there will be no other options.
- Husband wants girls to quit. My husband does not want them to skate there anymore, because he feels it is not safe. We just paid for the club session, and my husband has agreed to have them finish the session. They both want to continue to skate, but my husband feels betrayed by the attitudes at the rink, and by the non-committal response he received from the girls’ coach, who he believed had been looking out for their best interests.
I am not saying that my girls are blameless, as they may have been concentrating and made mistakes, but I honestly do not believe that it is possible that all of these incidents are their fault. I am willing to give lessons another try with another day/time, and take them myself, but I don’t know when they will practice. I don’t want them to quit skating, but I am absolutely stumped as to what to do. Suggestions?
From C.L., mom to a singles skater
As a frequent volunteer ice monitor I get complaints all the time about kids not moving out of the way. Our club even had a meeting about jumping lanes, spins in the middle, the lutz corner, etc. Often times I tell the kids to watch more carefully for the skater in the orange vest. Does it work….not really. I have noticed that if there are more than 20 skaters on the ice it’s going to be frustrating for all. Our club has rules about “group skating.” Most coaches will tell the girls to stop when this happens. Our higher level skaters are fast and perform the difficult jumps. I swear I see them circling the ice looking for an opening much like an airplane trying to land at LaGuardia. It is frustrating?….you bet. We don’t offer high and low freestyle because our club can’t afford it and ice time is limited during hockey season. We do have collisions but it doesn’t happen every session.
Here are my suggestions for this parent:
1st – talk to your coach about teaching your skaters on ice safety
2nd – have your skaters talk to the high level skaters and ask them for input (this creates a relationship of trying to work together)
3rd – Ask rink manager when the ice is less crowded and re-work your schedule to attend ice at that time
4th – attend freestyle session yourself (you may see things differently than your husband)
Last point…crowded freestyle sessions can be dangerous. Your skater should be very aware of everyone around her during these sessions.
Mommia mom to a singles skater
These stories always make me mad. n my opinion, 9 and 10 year old girls do not purposefully cause the issues. The older skaters should know better. That said, there may be unwritten rules they are unaware of – the kind that is assumed everyone knows. For example, at our rink it is assumed everyone knows that the skater whose music is playing has the right of way on the ice. However, this is not posted anywhere, and I find there are still skaters who are unaware of it. Thankfully, we seem to be blessed with teen skaters who are helpful (yes, there are teens in this world who think of people other than themselves. LOL) and don’t do the things you described. My advice is to have your husband or yourself at rinkside. Make sure you are visible to the other skaters, and make sure they know you are the parent of the girls. Basically, just make sure your presence is known and that you are watching. That may be all it takes. I find that usually no one will do anything if they know they are being watched. Perhaps pull out a video camera to tape your dc – and darn it if those other skaters keep getting caught on tape.
SeasonedSk8rmom, synchro skating mom and mom to a singles and synchro skater
The family that is having problems with the safety of their skaters, my heart goes out to your daughters. I remember how difficult it was for my daughter when she started skating on ice time that had high level skaters. She was very afraid and most of the time she will stand next to the boards and watch the higher level skaters skate, instead of practice. I found that the best time for my daughter to skate was in the morning. The morning ice time was not as crowded as the afternoon ice time at our rink. The morning skaters were too tired to be mean and were often times more respectful of the other skaters. I think morning ice skaters feel that if you are getting up that early to skate than you deserve some respect. I also realized that the morning ice was more economically beneficial. My daughter would often get to the rink in the morning and have the whole ice to herself.
You could also talk with other low level skaters parents and maybe get their opinion on the matter and also take a petition to your coach, rink manager, rink skating director, and club president, requesting separate ice time for lower level skaters. If you get enough support from other lower level skating parents the rink officials may see that there is a need to change their ice time policy.
If your rink does not offer morning ice and you have exhausted all options regarding who you can submit a grievance to, with the rink (coaches, rink manager, rink skating director, and club president), if your daughters still want to skate, and you are not able to switch practice ice time than you may need to consider another rink or quit skating. I hope that if you feel that your daughters have to quit skating please try to make this option a last resort. Take into consideration when making this your final decision to find out how serious your daughters are about skating and make it clear why you are making this decision for your daughters. I hope this helps, Seasonedsk8rmom
Sk8rmomp, mother of a male figure skater
If you feel your girls are unsafe, then stop skating on that session. Your children’s safety comes first. They are not going to love skating if they are continually intimidated. When DS was younger and less skilled, he refused to go onto the earlier sessions because he didn’t feel comfortable. People were moving too fast. He is now able skate on the early sessions and looks out for the little ones himself.
It seems like you are getting no support from the management or the club. This is terrible, but the number one issue is your children’s safety. It doesn’t matter who’s creating the situation. If there has already been contact and falling down, this is unacceptable. I totally believe that your children are trying their best to follow the rules, but if others are not sharing the ice, then no matter who’s fault it is, you need to remove your children for their safety. A good example is a car vs. pedestrian. Yes, the pedestrian had the right of way, but the car wins every time, and was it worth it to prove a point? Nope.
Find another time to skate and then when you are finished with your commitment to the rink for the ice sessions, look for another place that is more convenient (or ask for a refund explaining the situation). It is not worth your family’s aggravation. Let the rink know in a letter and in politically correct neutral language what the situation was that made you leave the rink (documentation and names, times and situations always give more weight to your letter. CC it to the club. They need to know that their bottom line is affected because of this situation.
Our club doesn’t have ice monitors and there are not enough skaters to have a separation between high and low test skaters except in the summer, and even then, the mid-level skaters get lumped in with the high test skaters and it’s not a happy situation. There is still tension, but that is the way it is (everyone makes the best of it). No one is entitled to bully. There is a code of conduct, but if no one is going to enforce it, it’s not worth the paper it’s printed on. If I saw my skater being a bully, I would stop it right away, and so should each IceParent or IceCoach. Luckily I don’t have to worry about that. He doesn’t want to injure anyone and is very careful of the little ones. After all, they have as much right to be on the ice as he does, and he knows this.
It’s not appropriate for the higher level skaters to act the way you are describing, but it seems like the situation will not change, even though you have tried. Unfortunately this is not uncommon, but not all rinks are like this. Find another one. Even public sessions are good, when your skaters are older, or more competent, then they will feel more comfortable on sessions like this.
Children often can sense when their parents are unhappy or worried and that will not help the situation. Get out of there. Find alternatives. They exist. Come to our rink, we would welcome you! So will others, I know it!!
Good luck!
From Allison Scott, mother of an Olympian and blogger at Life on the Edge
Wow. There are a couple of clues here that are really concerning: First, the coach is the rink manager? They have FS-1 and FS-2 on the ice with teen boys doing Axels? FS 1& 2 should be concentrating on what they are doing, not watching for freight trains every second. This is not as much your problem as it is a club and management problem. Saying that they are “not obeying the rules” is ridiculous. The posted rules are usually the STARS rules (that’s the rink managers association). I don’t know what Xan would say, but as a parent, I would be looking for some alternatives – like coaching on public ice until the girls are able to feel comfortable with their own skills and can handle the bigger and faster skaters. Then, I’d be having a serious conversation with the rink manager / coach. This is a recipe for some serious problems; there is also a rink liability if there are no controls, like numbers on a session. For right now, get those kids off the session and suggest to the coach that private lessons will cease if you don’t all find an adequate solution. In this instance, money may talk. That’s a pretty hardball approach, but your kids are your assets. You protect your assets.
From Xan, mother of a show skater and Jr. Nationals competitor, current figure skating coach, adult figure skater, and blogger at Xanboni!
-
- Her girls not obeying rules. For now, accept this as true. Lower level skaters sometimes run up against the rules without knowing they are doing it. To counter this, have them skate only with a coach for the next couple of weeks, with the specific mandate to have the coach observe them and explain the rules as they go. In the meantime, see if you can get the parents of an older skater who is a worst offender to mentor your girls. Ask if she can “babysit” them during a couple of practice sessions to show them what they are doing wrong. Pay her a babysitting rate for this.
- No one’s policing the ice. Girls are getting knocked down.This is a huge problem, and both issues are the same problem. If co-opting the enemy doesn’t work, this family needs to find some allies among the coaches and the other parents. Complain to club leadership. If it’s a USFS club, send a letter to Susi Wehrli at USFS (who manages, among other things, clubs and parent programs). Send a letter to the Professional Skaters Assn listing the names of all the coaches who are tolerating this situation. If kids are actually getting hurt, complain to your alderman. Complain to the local newspaper. Keep complaining. Find other parents who are also frustrated, you can’t be the only ones. Poorly policed ice is the major factor in accidents. Well-run practice ice has an upper limit of 25-30 free style skaters, fewer if it’s a mixed level session with low and high skaters, and fewer still if it’s high skaters only doing multiple rotation jumps. You pay a premium for practice ice because it is monitored by nonpartisan adults, and has fewer skaters. Well policed mixed level ice should have limits on moves– no complete Senior Moves patterns, no triple jumps, no Intermediate and above full program run-throughs, for instance. Lower level skaters ALWAYS get the right of way even when they are in the wrong (that’s just common sense). However, you have to tolerate the other kids yelling at them when they are in the wrong or doing something dangerous. If people are literally getting KNOCKED DOWN on practice ice, that’s ridiculous. I have never seen that. Accidental collisions yes; immature games of chicken, yes. But actual collisions should be rare, and are unacceptable. I can’t believe the coaches are tolerating this.
- Management won’t help. My guess is that dad went in there guns blazing and got their backs up. Try some of these other solutions, and then if things still don’t change go back, eat some humble pie, and try again. “We don’t want to quit, but we’re really concerned about everyone’s safety and we just don’t know what the girls are doing wrong.” Ask the manager to come and observe a session. This will stop the problem in its tracks, at least for that session. Every time the crap starts up again, go in again, asking for HELP not for change.
- Husband wants girls to quit. Don’t quit. At the very least, the girls will eventually take on the character of the practice session and grow an unpleasant attitude of their own, at least while on the ice. Then just make sure they don’t bring it home with them. But also ask yourself if you really want to be part of a program that tolerates this kind of behavior.
Well, readers? What do you think? What would you do if this happened at your rink? Would people tolerate it or would they shrug it off? What should the mom do? Should she keep her kids on the ice or shake the dust from their feet and never come back?
Photo credits:
Near-air collision: tghh on Flickr.com Creative Commons
Ship vs. Kayak: anoldent on Flickr.com Creative Commons
-
Helicopter Mom
-
lynnemv
-
pghicemom
-
http://www.Halushki.com Jozet at Halushki
-
http://raisingfigureskaters.com/ Deb Chitwood
-
Amy
-
Sandra
-
tinyskaters
-
http://twitter.com/icemom icemom
-
http://twitter.com/icemom icemom
-
Anonymous
-
fffrozensolidmom
-
Anonymous
-
fffrozensolidmom











Facebook
Twitter
RSS