Posted in Coaches, Etiquette, Featured Articles, Rink culture | View Comments
Soliciting: What’s a Figure Skating Parent’s Responsibility?
Sharpen your pencils! Let’s take a little pop quiz:
1. Which of these is appropriate?
Scenario one: A coach posts a flyer on the rink bulletin board. The flyer has her photo, lists her coaching credentials, a brief skating résumé, and her contact information. The figure skating club has offered space on the rink bulletin board to any coach who wants to post the same information about him or herself.
Scenario two: A coach posts a flyer on the rink bulletin board. The flyer has her photo, lists her coaching credentials, a brief skating résumé, and her contact information.
The flyer also contains a promise to make any skater a star on the ice. “Don’t have that Axel yet? You’ll have it in a month if you’re my student,” the coach wrote on the flyer. The figure skating club has offered space on the rink bulletin board to any coach who wants to post the same information about him or herself.
a. Scenario one
b. Scenario two
c. Both scenario one and two are appropriate
d. Neither scenario one nor two is appropriate
2. A parent is in the stands talking to her friends about her skater’s new figure skating coach. The skater recently switched coaches and the parent is amazed at the progress her skater has made in just a few short weeks. She tells her friends that the coach is amazing, that the coach’s skills are outstanding, and that anyone who is serious about skating would hire this coach.
This is an example of:
a. Promotion
b. Tampering
c. Advertisement
d. Solicitation
3. Your skater and his friend have different coaches. Both figure skaters are working on the same set of moves in the field. Friend suggests to your skater that they practice the patterns together. Friend begins to coach your skater to help your skater improve his moves. “Let me show you what my coach does with me,” Friend says.
Is there anything wrong with this?
a. Yes
b. No
4. A synchronized skating team is forming at the figure skating club across town. Your skater has been involved in her home club’s synchro team for a couple of years, but also has friends on the new team. Her friends on the new team beg your skater to join their team because it’s going to be such a fun year, they have so many talented skaters, and fees are less than at your skater’s home club. One skater sends you a Facebook message to ask you if your skater can join their synchro team; another asks you about it every time you see her.
Is this appropriate behavior?
a. Yes
b. No
5. A coach in your rink has been very successful with his students. At a competition, you and he begin a conversation while waiting for your skater to change in the locker room. The coach tells you that he really admires your skater and thinks your skater is a talented, hard-working kid. “Skater is just the kind of kid I like to coach,” he says. “Skater reminds me of my Novice-level skater, and you know Novice Skater did so well at Sectionals.”
Is this appropriate behavior?
a. Yes
b. No
6. A good friend of yours pulls you aside at the rink and tells you that she’s thinking about making a coaching change for her skater. She asks you some questions about your skater’s coach: Are you happy with the coach? Is the coach approachable? Does the coach have a good relationship with you? With your skater?
Is this appropriate behavior?
a. Yes
b. No
7. One of your skater’s friends approaches your skater, who is working on a jump. Friend watches Skater as Skater tries and tries to land a jump. Friend finally tells Skater, “It took me only three lessons to learn that jump. I bet if you used my jump coach, too, you’d have that jump in three lessons, too.”
Is this appropriate behavior?
a. Yes
b. No
8. Your skater placed last – again – at a competition. A coach with many successful skaters approaches you and asks to speak to you confidentially. The coach tells you that your current coach doesn’t have good skills and isn’t very qualified to coach skaters. “I could take your skater further than the other coach ever could,” this coach tells you.
What should you do?
a. Tell your coach about the conversation
b. Thank the coach for telling you the truth about your current coach
c. Nothing
d. Research both coaches to see which one is better
The Professional Skaters Association has rules about soliciting, promotion, and tampering. Most figure skating clubs have rules that prohibit soliciting and tampering, too. Coaches receive training about what they can and cannot do to build their coaching business. Despite club rules, parents often remain ignorant about soliciting, promotion, and tampering. Here’s what the three mean:
Promotion. Coaches are allowed to promote themselves as coaches to the general public as long as the method of promotion is available to any coach and the message is intended for anyone interested in figure skating. Promotion can include a coach’s figure skating résumé and coaching credentials as well as coaching philosophy. Coaches should not promise to make any child a star skater.
Tampering. Tampering can be as little as a coach saying to someone else’s student: You should hold that spin for three revolutions before exiting. It can be cozy-ing up to another coach’s skater – arranging to meet the mom for coffee, giving the skater high fives after practices, or inviting the skater to go mini-golfing with her skaters after practice ice.
Solicitation. Solicitation almost always happens on the sly. A parent, skater, or coach will approach a person and suggest that the person change figure skating coaches.
- You should switch because this coach has really successful skaters.
- You should switch because this coach is more qualified than yours.
- You should join our synchro team because we’re going to be awesome.
- I hate to see you throw your money away on bad coaching.
What should parents do if they witness solicitation or tampering?
- Tell your skater’s coach.
- Talk to the club president.
- Let the rink manager know.
Why all the fuss? What’s wrong with letting friends know that they’re wasting their money on poor coaching? Why can’t coaches build their businesses by approaching skaters and letting them know that they think they’d be a good fit as a coach for that skater? If I’m proud of the work my figure skater and his coach are doing, why can’t I tell people?
Solicitation and tampering are like gasoline and matches. Want to destroy a figure skating club? Pit coaches against one another and have them send their parents out to recruit as many new skaters as possible. Let’s face it: not everyone at the rink likes one another. Not all the coaches get along. We have different values, different goals, and different philosophies. It’s not better it’s different. When a person or a group of people begins to assert that their coach is better, other people feel threatened and it builds resentment. That’s not the way to encourage peace and harmony on the ice.
The answers. I totally made up these questions, so my answers aren’t the final word. I don’t pretend to be an ethics expert, but here’s what I think is right.
1. a – scenario two sounds like the coach is promising skaters the moon and stars. It’s unrealistic and slimy. Technically, I don’t think it’s tampering or soliciting because it’s out in the open, but I’m uncomfortable with it.
2. d – solicitation. I know people, good people, who have talked up their kids’ coach in the stands. “Jenny has her double twisty thing because her coach spent 15 minutes working on it with her. It’s just good coaching.” Um. Stop. Please.
3. a – Yes, I think this is tampering by proxy. Sure, the other coach isn’t offering your kid the suggestions herself, but just as a parent can solicit for a coach, I think that a skater can tamper with another coach’s skater. It’s one thing for skaters to work together, play add-on, or give one another a quick suggestion. It’s another thing for a kid to give another skater a lesson.
4. b – No, I think recruiting skaters for another club’s synchro team is soliciting. It’s O.K. for skaters to tell their friends about when try-outs will be held. That’s fine. Beyond that, this is a great way to cause ill will between two clubs and two synchronized skating teams.
5. b – No, I think that flattering another coach’s students is soliciting. It’s pretty indirect, but it gets the parent thinking about maybe switching coaches.
6. a – I’m going with Yes on this one. The friend approached you for information about your skater’s coach, not the other way around. She’s seeking information, you’re not pushing it on her. I think this is perfectly fine.
7. b – No, a skater should not tell another skater that his coach is better. That’s bratty. And it’s solicitation.
8. a – Tell your skater’s coach about the conversation. You don’t want your skater’s coach learning about it later and then feeling hurt that you didn’t tell her right away. If you suspect someone’s soliciting, just report it to the rink manager or the club president. Let them make the call about whether it’s unethical or not. Your conscience will be clean.
Let the debate begin! Do you disagree with me on my quiz answers? I’d love to hear your take on them. Have you witnessed tampering or solicitation? What happened?
What did you do about it? It’s O.K. if you did nothing. I did nothing about solicitation once, too. I’m not proud of it, but I didn’t know any better. You can throw out a situation for everyone to discuss, too. Please share in the comments.
Do you have a question for Ice Mom or a big dilemma for the Advisory Board? I’m set for this Friday and next Friday, but December 17, 24, and 31 are wide open. Do you have a suggestion for a post you’d like to read? I’d love to hear from you. Send me an e-mail! IceMom.Diane@gmail.com
Announcements:
- Have you voted in and viewed the results for the holiday gift polls?
- Can you take a minute to fill out the Ballet Survey?
- Stop by on Monday, December 6. Author Kate Messner will talk about her new young adult book Sugar and Ice and answer reader questions. Messner’s book was just named one of Amazon.com’s Best Books of the Month for the month of December (Best Books for Kids). Pretty cool, hey?
Photo credits:cohdra_100_0697rmt [pencil waste and pencil]: cohdra on MorgueFile.com
DSCN2886 [pencil shavings]: squaio on MorgueFile.com
october_27_002 [pencil can]: jdurham on MorgueFile.com
Pencil_Sharpener_8114 (19): alvimann on MorgueFile.com
pencil002 [stubby]: mconnors on MorgueFile.com
cohdra100_1428 [paper schnibbles]: cohdra on MorgueFile.com
quietplz: taliesin on MorgueFile.com
IMG_1479_j [cheat notes]: badrobot on MorgueFile.com
017 [fire]: nacu on MorgueFile.com
Fire_Alarm_2922: alvimann on MorgueFile.com
firealarm2a: jdurham on MorgueFile.com
sprinkler: seemann on MorgueFile.com
kevinrosseel_01ae [fire hydrant]: kevinrosseel on MorgueFile.com
-
Guest
-
http://icemom.net Ice Mom
-
Guest
-
Guest
-
Guest
-
Guest
-
Guest
-
Guest
-
Erica
-
Anonymous
-
Sk8rzmom
-
guest
-
Erica
-
Mom
-
Anonymous
-
Anonymous
-
Sk8rzmom
-
sk8t mom
-
Anonymous
-
The Same Anonymous
-
Anonymous
-
Sk8rzmom
-
Sk8rzmom
-
ifyousaygo










Facebook
Twitter
RSS